Archive
2013.10.01
The challenge: creating a pillar-free theater space
Taking on the challenge of "supporting a super-tall tower"
Structural Engineering the challenge of building a super-tall tower on a column-free space
Structural Engineering Department: Yoji Ishibashi
Construction Supervision: Megatruss achieves unprecedented precision
Engineering Department Yuji Nakajo
This project was full of difficult challenges, but the structural engineer took on what could be considered the most challenging theme.
What answer did they come up with to the difficult problem of placing a super-tall tower on top of a pillar-less theater space?
Furthermore, while facing adversity, such as changes to the construction method after the Great East Japan Earthquake, Construction Supervision supervisor was keenly aware ofthe "unity" that Mitsubishi Jisho Design is proud of.
Tackling the challenge of building a super-tall tower on a column-free space
Structural Engineering: Yoji Ishibashi, Structural Engineering Department
"To build a unique building with a theater and a super-high rise tower directly above it, with high earthquake resistance." This was the main task we were given in this project. Since the theater is below, there can't be any columns there. We used a "megastructure" method that adopted a steel megatruss to secure a column-free space of about 40m width across the theater itself and place the super-high rise tower on it. A truss is a structural form in which steel and other building materials are combined in a triangle. It is an efficient form that resists forces with a straight axial force on the materials, and is often used for steel towers and iron bridges. You can imagine that the theater part is an open space from the first to fourth floors of the Kabukiza, and the super-high rise tower built above the column-free space is supported by a huge iron bridge. It is one of the largest megatrusses used in high-rise buildings in Japan, and we took on a completely unprecedented and difficult case, such as designing it while taking into account the construction method. Although we felt a great deal of pressure, it was very rewarding.
We created a structural transition floor from the super high-rise tower to the column-free space below, and placed a mega truss, which also functions as a switchover between the offices and theater, and is also used as a machine room for both the offices and theater, resulting in a fusion of structure and function. There were many twists and turns with each department before we settled on this.
A delicate theme: combining the reproduction of Japanese architecture with steel construction
The theater section faced a major hurdle in maintaining the traditional design of the fourth-generation Kabukiza, which was constructed with reinforced concrete, in a steel-framed structure. Fitting the structural steel beams into the various facade inherited from the previous Kabukiza was extremely challenging, as we had to figure out how to fit them into the narrow dimensions. The full-scale inspection of the truss steel beams was particularly memorable. In the winter of 2011, designers, Construction Supervision, Structural Engineering, master carpenters, and tilers all gathered at a workshop in Fukui Prefecture. Under the supervision of a master carpenter skilled in CAD, we spread full-scale cross-sectional drawings across the entire floor, carefully inspecting the fit and construction procedures, and then plotting the steel beams. I remember the workshop being extremely cold, with almost no heating. Aside from the dynamism of this megastructure, another major challenge was tackling the delicate theme of simultaneously recreating Japanese-style architecture and incorporating steel-frame construction.
This project required a design that met both extreme requirements: boldness and the utmost care. I was overwhelmed by the sense of scale on many occasions, such as when I first saw the huge truss members in the factory, when I witnessed their assembly on site, and when I witnessed the special jacking-up work that was used to deal with deformation during construction. Also, seeing up close the process of gradually recreating the traditional exterior of the Kabukiza with steel frames reminded me of the full-scale inspection in Fukui during the harsh winter, and I felt an indescribable sense of accomplishment.
While verifying the fit and construction procedure on a full-scale cross-sectional drawing,
Write the steel frame.
Megatruss achieves unprecedented precision
In charge of Construction Supervision Engineering Department, Yuji Nakajo
Looking back on this project from the perspective of Construction Supervision, there were many unprecedented aspects, making it extremely difficult to predict what would happen next. Construction Supervision of the gigantic megatruss was one example. Structural Engineering required the adoption of a special construction method in which the upper columns were jacked up in response to the gradual deflection of the megatruss during construction. To ensure high precision, jacking up had to be performed at each construction step, and with no precedent, we pondered how to ensure construction quality. Ultimately, it is rare to see such high-precision jacking achieved with such effectiveness. While we've heard that other companies have attempted projects in the past that have failed, I believe the success of this project was due to the careful initial planning, which allowed it to proceed smoothly.
The goal of maintaining facade and interior spaces of the previous Kabukiza theater was to largely replicate the original, posing numerous challenges, making this a truly unique project. Approximately six months after construction began, just as full-scale planning began, the Great East Japan Earthquake struck, and damage to the theater's ceilings and walls was reported across the country. This necessitated a comprehensive review of the Kabukiza theater, and we sought ways to ensure greater safety while maintaining the design as originally planned. Immediately following the earthquake, with no established legal standards or methods, we engaged in repeated discussions with the designers and, after much trial and error, ultimately decided to change the theater's ribbed ceiling (a large, curved ceiling) from a suspended ceiling to a "rigid ceiling" attached directly to steel beams. We also decided to replace the theater's Narihira wall (a large, diamond-patterned wall on both sides of the theater) with a 24x15m, solid wall supported by steel beams. This significant change, made during on-site construction, naturally placed a strain on the site. However, our design, Construction Supervision, and structural departments came together to explain the necessity of this and were able to convince the client and the contractor, ultimately improving the earthquake resistance. This was a time when we really got a feel for the power of teamwork that is unique to our company.
Roof tiles that are "unprecedented in the past 1,200 years" and challenge wind resistance
The roofing of the Kabukiza was also a difficult task. The roof of the Kabukiza is made up of 100,000 original tiles and ridgepole tiles over 3 meters high. Normally, there is no skyscraper built right behind a tiled roof. The roof is exposed to strong winds blowing down, so the tiles need to be extremely wind-resistant. We calculated the wind resistance and put together the optimal specifications for the tiles. When the construction actually started, it was a much more time-consuming task than usual for the tile craftsmen, and it ended up being an extremely unusual method. There was some resistance, with some saying, "We've never done this in our 1,200-year history." The roof of the Kabukiza has the volume of eight regular kuri buildings, so it's certainly understandable that they were resisting. One extra screw to each tile means 100,000 extra tasks. Still, this is probably the first time in history that we've ever laid tiles, so we explained the necessity of it and they finally agreed.
This project faced a number of challenging hurdles, and I believe that the Kabukiza site was a continuous series of adversities for not only Construction Supervision but also the designers. In particular, with only two years to complete the construction after the earthquake, the contractors were reluctant to make any changes to the design. This is understandable from their perspective, but the changes were absolutely necessary. At such times, it was very reassuring to see the staff working on site listen to us sincerely and professionally. Our staff came together to tackle these difficult challenges and overcome the adversity, which ultimately led to a wonderful result. I am proud of the unity at Mitsubishi Jisho Design.
This special feature was compiled in 2013. The titles of each person in charge are those from that time.
OTHER INTERVIEWS
Featured GINZA KABUKIZA
The technology and experience cultivated by Mitsubishi Jisho Design has been brought together
The need to preserve history within the framework of urban regeneration
GINZA KABUKIZA architectural design and construction supervision services
Project Manager
Architectural Design Department 4 Kazunori Nomura
Featured GINZA KABUKIZA
The former Kabukiza
Inheriting “invisible goodness.”
Chief Designer
Architectural Design Department 4 Kazuhiro Ishibashi
Featured GINZA KABUKIZA
The image of the Kabukiza Theater that has been loved for many years
Design: Antique materials convey an aura of history and add elegance to the building
Architectural Design Satoru Satoru Sumitani
Design Construction Supervision Design Construction Supervision of a high-performance office tower that harmonizes with the Kabukiza Theater
Architectural Design Department IV Takushu Arai
Featured GINZA KABUKIZA
The challenge: creating a pillar-free theater space
Taking on the challenge of "supporting a super-tall tower"
Structural Engineering the challenge of building a super-tall tower on a column-free space
Structural Engineering Department: Yoji Ishibashi
Construction Supervision: Megatruss achieves unprecedented precision
Engineering Department Yuji Nakajo
Featured GINZA KABUKIZA
While inheriting the design of its predecessor,
Updated for the latest features
Mechanical MEP Engineering Making use of the previous design to create a more functional building
Mechanical MEP Engineering Department Atsushi Nakamura
Electrical MEP Engineering Integrating the functions unique to a dedicated Kabuki theater
Yasunori Yamaguchi, MEP Engineering Department
Featured GINZA KABUKIZA
As a "complex cultural hub"
New Kabukiza Theatre
Urban Planning: The New Kabukiza was launched as a multi-cultural hub
Planning & Project Consulting Department Takeshi Tomita
Landscape Buildings and gardens are integrated under the theme of "tei-oku-ichinyo"
Urban Environmental Planning Department, Noriyuki Matsuo
Update : 2013.10.01